Guide To Best Compost Bins

Guide To Best Compost Bins

Every year, thousands and thousands of new products become available to consumers. Compost bins are no different, and manufacturers regularly declare new inventions to be ‘the best compost bin on the market.'

Finding the right composter, however, is a difficult task. Different people value different features. For example, some may prioritize size while others may prioritize durability. Many other factors need to be considered, such as price, utility, and attractiveness.

Using composters in garden

This buying guide offers you a comprehensive analysis of the most important factors when it comes to choosing the best composter to buy. Whether you are an experienced composter or someone who is attempting composting for the first time, this guide should prove itself to be a useful and valuable source of information.

By identifying what you need most in a compost bin before buying, you can save yourself the regret of choosing to invest in something that you don’t need. This buying guide seeks to ease your decision-making process by explaining the pros and cons of several popular models.

In this guide, five state-of-the-art compost bins are examined, in detail, to help you identify what you need. First, however, it is important to understand exactly what a compost bin is, and the functions that it serves.

*Notice: On mobile devices, scroll right to see entire table​

What Is A Compost Bin?

A compost bin is a container used to temporarily store natural waste as it decomposes to become fertilizer. According to David Beaulieu, a composter is ‘designed to facilitate the decomposition of organic matter through proper aeration and moisture retention.'

A compost bin serves two primary purposes: a means of disposal for organic waste like uneaten food, and to produce fertilizer. A composter makes it possible for you to produce your compost, ensuring that you have control over the nutrients fertilizing your garden.

using a composter in backyard

The fertilizer obtained from composting is rich in nutrients, meaning that agricultural yield is significantly improved when it is applied. In addition to this, is serves as a natural pesticide by protecting the outer layers of the soil.

In a compost bin, organic matter is broken down by living organisms. In the presence of oxygen, bacteria consume the waste to produce heat, ammonium and carbon dioxide. Ammonium is a significant source of nitrogen, a nutrient crucial to the development of plants.

Compost And Fertilization

Compost is an excellent fertilizer. This means that is made up of chemicals that enhance the growth of plants by providing additional nutrients. In addition to this, compost is good at retaining moisture which ensures that plans have a sufficient supply of water.

Compost has been used as a means of fertilizing the soil for thousands of years. The fact that it is acceptable means that it retains moisture and nutrients exceptionally well. It also prevents soil erosion, meaning that by using you can save soil from being lost.

The porous sediment makes it easier for plant roots to grow because the small spaces between the grains of the compost will allow air to flow in and out of the soil.

Different compost bins produce various types of fertilizers. Some produce compost in a liquid form while others produce reliable, soil-like fertilizer. This is an important factor that you must consider when you choose the compost bin that is right for you.

According to Sarah James, an expert in plant biology, ‘the main ingredients in most popular fertilizers are Nitrogen, Phosphorus, and Potassium, which are three of the essential elements required for plant growth.'

healthy grass and soil pattern

Nitrogen, which is provided by the ammonium produced when organic matter undergoes decomposition, increases the speed at which the plant grows while helping it produce flowers and stems.

Phosphorus, which is often much less abundant in unfertilized soil, aids plants in the process producing essential oils and starches in which energy is stored. It is also used in the making of chlorophyll, which is utilized by the plant to produce energy via photosynthesis.

Potassium is also essential in the process of photosynthesis. James also explains that it is used to ‘help to build protein and fight off diseases.'

These ingredients are all essential to healthy plant growth. If even one is missing, then the agricultural yield will likely be small.

Fertilizers also enrich the soil with minerals like zinc, magnesium, and sulfur. By making your compost, you can independently choose the minerals and nutrients that you want your fertilizer to contain, which allows you to tailor the mix to your plants personally.

Aerobic And Anaerobic Composting – Which Is Best?

Certain conditions are required to ensure that matter decomposes to useable compost. In general, there are two ways in which this process can occur: aerobically and anaerobically.

An aerobic composting system is a system in which decomposition can occur in an oxygen-rich environment. Some of the bacteria involved in breaking down biological waste can thrive only in aerobic systems.

Anaerobic systems limit aeration (the flow of air) to promote the growth of organisms that can survive in the absence of oxygen.

composter with dual chambers

Each method of composting has its benefits and drawbacks. Anaerobic composting requires little maintenance, while aerobic composting needs regular care. If you are not able to spend time monitoring air and moisture conditions or be able to turn waste to ensure an even exposure to oxygen, then an anaerobic composting bin may be the best choice for you.

However, in anaerobic conditions, the fermentation process occurs at a slower rate. This means if you require a high output of fertilizer then an aerobic compost bin may be the better choice.

Benefits Of Aerobic Composting Include:

  • The gasses produced as waste undergoes decomposition are less pungent
  • Weed seeds are destroyed due to the release of heat
  • Faster rate of compost production
  • ​Carbon dioxide is much less harmful to the environment than methane, the main byproduct of anaerobic decomposition
  • Dangerous pathogens are killed due to the high temperatures

Benefits Of Anaerobic Composting Include:

  • Requires less time to maintain
  • The fertilizer produced is liquid and fibrous
  • The compost produced is often longer lasting

If you are relatively new to composting, then an anaerobic composter may be the better option because it requires less skill and experience to use effectively. However, if you value the quality of the fertilizer, then an aerobic composter may be the better choice.

Budget And Price

As with all purchases, the pricing of the compost bin is likely to be a significant factor in the decision that you take. The price-range of the different compost bins vary from $90 to $215.

It is important to understand that buying a compost bin is a long-term investment. The products mentioned all come with a warranty period included, meaning that you can have it replaced at any time should problems arise.

The features of each composter justify their prices, meaning that the more expensive compost bins will obviously have more features. The products that are referred to in this guide have been carefully selected to match different possible needs.

Our Top Recommendations

Lets Look at top compost bins available on the market:

Enviro World FreeGarden Earth Compost Bin


  • Manufacturer: Enviro World Corp.
  • Item weight: 18 pounds
  • Product Dimensions: 35 32 28 inches
  • Origin: Canada
  • ​Manufactured of 100% recycled content
  • 1-year warranty included
Two Envirocycle Composting Tumbler Bins

Our Rating

The Enviro World FreeGarden Earth Compost Bin is one of the most efficient, durable, and economical compost bins on the market. This Made In Canada compost bin features 100% recycled content and is designed with an emphasis on sustainability and efficiency. A BESTSELLER on Amazon!

Other features that have made this compost bin a bestseller include a single-unit main body construction for easy assembly, a strong structural design to provide structural integrity even in the most extreme weather conditions, also animal and pest resistant lids with a twisting feature that allows for variable ventilation control. The almost 20 inch (49.5cm) wide opening offers generous access for adding more material.

This compost bin boasts the highest rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars! It has been extremely well received by customers, and if composting is important to you, then the model should be well worth the investment.

"I have used several different kinds of composters over the years and found this one to be the best." - Amazon Review

Other highlights from customer reviews include "keeps out small critters", "easy 3-piece assembly", "capacity is larger than expected", "reasonable price" and "this is my second bin because the first one worked so great!".

The Enviro World FreeGarden Earth compost bin is definitely the best all-around compost bin in our review. Great features at a great price!

Redmon Green Culture Compost Bin


  • Manufacturer: Redmon
  • Item weight: 15 pounds
  • Product Dimensions: 31 26.5 5 inches
  • Origin: New Zealand
  • Four door access
  • Warranty must be requested upon purchase
Redmon Green Culture 65-Gallon Compost Bin in backyard

Our Rating

The Redmon Green Culture 65-Gallon Compost Bin is a very durable composter with a great focus on utility. This product is made of plastic and weather-resistant material and is composed of a total of four panels that are very easy to assemble or take apart for storage.

Also, a detailed guide is included that will help you learn the art of composting in a short amount of time. Four access doors are located at the bottom of the bin, which facilitate the removal of compost when ready. The lid lifts easily for convenient use and keeps animals and insects out of the container.

The ventilation system is very well executed, with ideally placed air slots that control the flow of oxygen. The dark color of the compost bin helps contain the heat produced during the fermentation reaction.

This product has been reviewed more than 200 times, and with an average rating of 4.3 stars, you can be sure that you are getting great value for your money. This convenient composter is the least expensive option available on the list, and at 54 dollars, is almost certainly a fantastic investment.

As the least expensive recommended item on this guide, this is likely the best option to choose if you have never composted before. It is very straight forward using process, and the least risky compost bin regarding budget capacity.

Yimby Tumbler Composter


  • Manufacturer: Yimby
  • Item weight: 30 pounds
  • Product Dimensions: 36 31 28 inches
  • Origin: Canada
  • Makes compost very quickly: in just two weeks
  • Warranty must be requested upon purchase
Yimby Tumbler Composter in Backyard

Our Rating

The third product recommended by this guide is called the Yimby Tumbler Composter. At a reasonable price of just under $95, this black composter could be the one for you. By turning the composter over using the handle provided every couple of days, you can expect to begin producing usable compost in as little as two weeks. The tumbling design of this product ensures that this is possible.

The tumbling design ensures that the entire batch of compost is aerated evenly and thoroughly. Another function that differentiates this product from the rest is the fact that it has two composting chambers. Having two chambers allows you to produce two separate batches of compost, meaning you can add organic waste to one side while the other is still curing.

The core of this composter is raised above the ground, as it sits on top of a stable structure. This protects the contents from the threat of rats. The chambers are durable, and because they are built out of polypropylene, direct sunlight poses no threat to the compost inside.

The steel frame that gives this product its stability is galvanized and thus corrosion resistant, meaning that it is perfect composter for outdoor use. As with the Redmon Composter mentioned previously, the Yimby Composter has adjustable vents that regulate oxygen flow.

If you are looking for a composter that is both durable and efficient, then look no further than the Yimby Tumbler Composter. It produces compost at an astonishing rate unmatched by any other composters on the marker and is extremely suited for outdoor use.

Good Ideas EZCJR- Compost Wizard


  • Manufacturer: Good Ideas
  • Item weight: 27 pounds
  • Product Dimensions: 22 23.5 30 inches
  • Origin: United States of America
  • Turning the compost is requires little effort due to the recessed handles
  • Warranty must be requested upon purchase
Good Ideas EZCJR-BLK 7-Cubic-Foot Compost Wizard Jr. in Backyard

Our Rating

This composting bin is very simple to use, and therefore ideal for new composters. It is excellent at retaining moisture, ensuring that organic material is always stored in moist conditions, regardless of the conditions outside.

The wheeled base makes it easy to transport this compost bin, so you won’t have any problems moving it around, even when it is filled up. A large, 12-inch wide hole makes it easy to access the contents inside, so you will be able to put in and pull out large quantities of compost.

The chamber is made of polyethylene, making it very durable and protecting it from pests like cats and foxes. The black color ensures that heat is absorbed, which aids in the composting process.

The handles are fashioned as part of the body of the composter. This means that they cannot be broken, even when a heavy amount of compost is being turned inside. Air flow may be an issue if used in areas with low air currents, but large holes can be drilled to solve this problem.

Rated 4.3 out of 5 stars by an incredible 502 customers, this model is by far the most popular out of the five being recommended. If you are relatively new to composting, then this compost bin should sufficiently satisfy all your needs.

Algreen Products Soil Saver Classic Compost Bin


  • Manufacturer: Algreen Products
  • Item weight: 27.5 pounds
  • Product Dimensions: 27 27 32 inches
  • Origin: Canada
  • Includes a large opening and two sliding doors to make transporting compost easy
  • Warranty must be requested upon purchase
Using Algreen Products Soil Saver Classic Compost Bin

Our Rating

The Algreen Soil Saver Compost Bin is a bulky composter that can, according to Algreen, ‘Produce rich organic dark compost humus in 6 to 8 weeks from food scraps, kitchen, and garden waste'.

It is very thick, which makes trapping heat inside much more efficient. The thickness of this compost bin protects the contents from pesky animals and insects. The compost that this bin produces is a rich and dark form of humus, which is extremely nutrient rich and promotes healthy plant growth.

This product has been designed with the environment in mind, as it is composed of only recycled materials.

The structure of this composter makes it easy to access the inside, with two sliding doors making removing compost a simple and easy task. Also, the self-watering lid ensures that the inside remains humid, which is ideal because it aids the decomposition process.

Having been rated 4.4 stars out of 5 by over 385 customers, you can be sure about what you are getting with this product. It will produce a high standard of fertilizer which will ensure that your plants grow healthy and fast. Also, a guide to composting is included in the purchase, which should make learning how to compost easier for you.


Having analyzed the composting market extensively, it has become clear that here are many different composting bins available on the market to choose from. This guide has listed five successful and fruitful compost bins that may suit your needs.

Before you choose to invest in a compost bin, it is important that you recognize what your needs are. If you require a significant amount of compost to fertilize your garden, you should prioritize volume over quality.

If composting is not an important part of your life then investing in a less expensive composter would make more sense. It is up to you to decide what product you require and how much you are willing to pay.

Everything You Need To Know About Composting

Hopefully, this guide has been a useful tool to help you determine the composter that is right for you. If you are new to composting then by now, you should have a reasonable understanding of how the composting process works. This should help make it easier for you to decide what model you need.

People more experienced with composters can use this guide as a reference to becoming familiar with the compost bins on the market today. Compost bins are great inventions that ensure that you help preserve the environment when fertilizing your plants.

Investing in a compost bin can be very rewarding. It helps protect the environment and simultaneously nourishes your crops, meaning that you kill two birds with one stone.

Leave a Comment: